Compare

Why not just use EasyOptOuts?

EasyOptOuts is $19.99/yr and Consumer Reports found it works. Here's what that price buys, and when Shield is worth more.

See an example report

EasyOptOuts is genuinely the cheapest credible option in this category, and Consumer Reports' own testing found it worked. For some people, $19.99 a year is the right answer. Read the full picture ↓

Bottom line

Pick EasyOptOuts if price is the deciding factor and US-only broker removal is your whole problem — it’s $19.99/year, the cheapest credible option, and Consumer Reports’ 2024 testing measured a 65% removal rate. Pick KnytX Shield if you want continuous monitoring with automatic re-filing, breach and stealer-log checks, or coverage outside the US, none of which a once-a-year sweep provides. Either way, start with Shield’s free tier: it costs $0 and includes a scan plus 3 real removals.

Side by side

KnytX Shield vs EasyOptOuts, feature by feature

Every row below is either a published price/policy or a third-party-reported figure — see sources at the bottom of this section. Checked 2026-07-12.

Feature comparison: KnytX Shield vs EasyOptOuts
Feature	KnytX Shield	EasyOptOuts
Annual price EasyOptOuts pricing per its own site, checked 2026-07. It’s the cheapest credible option in the category.	$107.88/yr ($8.99/mo Basic)	$19.99/yr
Independent effectiveness testing Consumer Reports, “Data Defense: Evaluating People Search Site Removal Services” (2024). See KnytX Shield’s own page for the full study citation and methodology.	Not yet independently tested — we publish our own numbers once we have real measured data, including if it’s not flattering	Consumer Reports’ 2024 “Data Defense” study measured a 65% removal rate for EasyOptOuts — one of the higher scores in that study
Geographic coverage	US, UK, EU, India, and Switzerland — CCPA, UK GDPR, GDPR, DPDPA, and Swiss FADP removal requests	US only
Continuous monitoring / re-listing	Continuous re-scanning and automatic re-submission once you’re in, as brokers re-list you	Not offered — annual flat-fee service, no ongoing monitoring or alerts reported
Breach and stealer-log exposure	Included via KnytX Vigil on paid tiers — breach and credential-exposure monitoring alongside broker removal	Not offered — broker opt-outs only
Free tier	Yes — scan + 3 real removals/year + DELETE Act filing assist	No free tier reported

Sources: Consumer Reports, "Data Defense" study (2024) — 65% removal rate for EasyOptOuts, EasyOptOuts pricing ($19.99/yr, checked 2026-07), KnytX pricing FAQ

The honest answer

Who each one is actually for

Choose EasyOptOuts if

Price is your primary constraint and $19.99/year fits your budget better than any subscription.
You only need US broker removal — EasyOptOuts is US-only, and that’s genuinely all some people need.
You don’t need continuous monitoring, breach alerts, or removal-status tracking — a lower-touch, lower-cost annual sweep is enough for you.

Choose KnytX Shield if

You want continuous monitoring and automatic re-filing when a broker re-lists you, not a once-a-year sweep.
You want breach and stealer-log exposure checks alongside broker removal, not broker removal alone.
You want a free tier to try before paying anything — 3 real removals and DELETE Act filing assist, not a paid-only product.
You have exposure outside the US — EasyOptOuts doesn’t cover UK, EU, or Indian brokers; Shield does.

Read the full breakdown

The honest answer here is simple: if price is your only constraint, EasyOptOuts is a legitimate choice and you should consider it. It costs $19.99 a year, the cheapest credible option in this category. Consumer Reports’ 2024 “Data Defense” study measured a 65% removal rate for it, one of the higher scores in the study. We cite the same study on Shield’s own page.

What $19.99/year actually buys

EasyOptOuts is a US-only, flat-fee annual service. It runs opt-out requests against a set of American broker sites once a year, at a price no subscription service can match. It doesn’t do continuous monitoring, breach checks, or coverage outside the US.

Data brokers commonly re-list removed records within three to six months. A once-a-year service catches that on its next annual cycle, not continuously. If your budget is genuinely $19.99/year and US-only broker removal is your whole problem, that’s an honest trade some people should make.

Where the trade stops making sense

Do you have exposure outside the US, need breach monitoring alongside broker removal, or want your data re-checked continuously? A flat annual sweep doesn’t cover that, regardless of price. That’s the real case for paying more. EasyOptOuts isn’t bad at what it does; it just does one thing once a year, and Shield does more.

Either way, start with what’s free. Shield’s free tier includes a real broker scan and 3 real removals a year at no cost, a reasonable way to see your exposure before you decide.

Sources: Consumer Reports, “Data Defense: Evaluating People Search Site Removal Services” (2024) — 65% removal rate reported for EasyOptOuts. EasyOptOuts pricing ($19.99/yr) checked 2026-07.

Questions

Is EasyOptOuts a scam?

No. It’s a real, low-cost service, and Consumer Reports’ own 2024 testing found a 65% removal rate — one of the better scores in that study. If US-only broker opt-outs at the lowest price is genuinely all you need, it’s a legitimate option.

Then why would anyone pay more?

EasyOptOuts is a flat annual sweep, not an ongoing service: no continuous monitoring, no re-listing alerts, no breach checks, US-only. If your data reappears three months later (which broker data commonly does), you’re on your own until the next cycle you pay for. Once you’re in, Shield runs continuously and covers more than broker removal.

Can I just start with EasyOptOuts and switch later?

Yes, and that’s a reasonable way to test the category cheaply. Broker removal requests filed under CCPA/GDPR/DPDPA are legally binding regardless of which company filed them, so switching services doesn’t undo work already done.

Does KnytX have anything at that price point?

Not a paid tier — but Shield’s free tier costs $0 and includes a real broker scan, 3 real removals per year, and DELETE Act filing assistance for California residents. For US-only, low-touch needs, that free tier plus an annual EasyOptOuts sweep is a genuinely reasonable combination; we’re not going to pretend otherwise.